Skip to content

We’re Not in Kansas Anymore

(originally written in September, 2026)

Say you’re blind, you live in Kansas City, and the grocery chain’s website won’t let you check out. The cart is there, the button is there, the screen reader just can’t find it. So you do the thing every business lobby in America has spent twenty-five years saying disabled people never do: you write to them. You describe the barrier. You tell them exactly which page. You give them three months.

Nothing happens. So you file in federal court under the Americans with Disabilities Act, which has required that website to be usable by you since before the website existed.

The following week, the grocery chain sues you.

Not a counterclaim in your case. A separate lawsuit, in Missouri state court, naming you, your lawyer, and your lawyer’s firm, asking a judge to declare your suit “abusive litigation.” To win, they don’t have to show your claim was false. They have to persuade the judge that the “primary purpose” of your suit was to get paid because defending it costs money, weighed on five factors. One factor is whether you’ve filed before. One is how settlement went, including offers you refused. Your three-month letter helps you on exactly one factor of the five. If you win the federal case, the Missouri statute gives that victory no explicit weight. If you lose the state one, you owe their fees for both suits, plus up to three times that on top. The statute names your lawyer and firm as defendants too, although it’s genuinely unclear whether they pay or merely get sued.

That’s Missouri Senate Bill 907, now section 537.1250 of the Revised Statutes of Missouri, in effect since August 28. Everything above is in the text. I’ll quote the text as we go, because the whole problem with this law is that nobody has been reading it, and for a while that included me.

I got this wrong in May

In May I wrote a piece about the federal ACCESS Act, the notice-and-cure bill Congress has reintroduced on a loop since 1999. In it I said states were finding better answers, and I pointed at Kansas and Missouri as the proportionate models. Missouri had just passed its bill unanimously, “without the partisan warfare” of the federal attempts, and I read the unanimity as a sign it was targeting the actual bad actors instead of the disabled person seeking access.

Every piece of coverage since, from the government-tech press to the defense bar, has described the enacted law as a 90-day remediation window. I believed it too.

Then I read the statute. It is not a remediation window. There is no notice requirement anywhere in it. It’s a new lawsuit, and it’s pointed at everyone.

What it actually is

The operative sentence, subsection 2(1):

“The attorney general under section 507.070 on behalf of a class of residents of this state who are subject to litigation that alleges any website or web content access violation, or any resident of this state who is subject to litigation that alleges any website or web content access violation, may file a civil action in any court of competent jurisdiction within this state against the party, attorney, or law firm that initiated such litigation for a determination as to whether such litigation alleging a website or web content access violation is abusive litigation.”

Read the trigger. “Subject to litigation that alleges any website or web content access violation.” Not litigation filed without notice. Not litigation filed inside some cure window. Any accessibility suit, full stop. Your careful letter and your three months of waiting do not prevent the counter-suit from being filed. Nothing you can do prevents it.

And read who “resident of this state” is, from the definitions:

“any individual residing in Missouri; any entity that has registered with the Missouri secretary of state’s office; or the state of Missouri or any political subdivision thereof, including all boards, commissions, agencies, institutions, authorities, and bodies politic and corporate of the state”

Any registered entity. A Delaware corporation headquartered in New Jersey with a Missouri registration is a Missouri resident for this purpose. And there is no requirement, anywhere in the section, that the original accessibility case was filed in Missouri. So a Missouri-registered company sued in the Southern District of New York can file this thing in Missouri state court against a New York plaintiff and a New York firm. New York and Florida produced about two thousand of these federal filings last year between them. Missouri produced eighty-something. This was never a law about Missouri’s docket.

And note that last clause of the definition. The state itself, every school district, every public university, every municipal body. The federal notice-and-cure bills, all ten of them, only ever touched Title III of the ADA, the part about stores and restaurants. Missouri handed the counter-suit to its Title II entities too. A public university sued over its website can now sue the student who sued it.

So what does the 90 days do? It’s a presumption, and it belongs to the defendant:

“A defendant who receives written notice of an alleged website or web content access violation and in good faith initiates substantial steps to correct it within ninety days shall have a rebuttable presumption that any subsequent claim for a website or web content access violation is abusive.”

The clock starts on written notice or on being served with the complaint, whichever comes first. So a plaintiff who files cold still starts the clock. “Good faith” and “substantial steps” are defined nowhere. And two sentences later the statute takes the presumption back if the site isn’t actually “corrected, as determined by the court, within ninety days.” The court decides what corrected means, against no technical standard, in a statute whose stated premise is that no technical standard exists.

Also read “any subsequent claim.” Not any subsequent claim by that plaintiff. Any subsequent claim by anyone. The first person to sue a business starts its clock, so their claim isn’t “subsequent.” The second person, who may never have heard of the first, walks into a presumption that they’re abusive. Whether that’s what the drafters meant, I genuinely can’t tell you. It’s what they wrote.

Here’s the part the coverage misses because it’s looking for a cure period. A state statute can’t touch a federal ADA case. The judge in the Eastern District of Missouri applies federal procedure and doesn’t care that 537.1250 exists. The accessibility case proceeds untouched. But that isn’t a flaw in the law. It’s the design. Missouri didn’t try to block federal filings. It left them alone and attached a price to the person who files one. It doesn’t stop you exercising a federal civil right. It makes you pay to defend a second lawsuit for having done so.

Kansas wrote it first, and Kansas wrote it with a conscience

I should have known this in May, because I’d written it in May. Kansas passed the Act Against Abusive Website Access Litigation in 2023. Missouri’s law is that act, section for section, with “or Web Content” inserted into the title. So I put the two texts next to each other.

Every substantive edit Missouri made runs the same direction.

Kansas opens with a purpose clause that reaffirms the state’s equal-access policy, acknowledges that disabled people “are empowered to enforce the right to equal access through litigation,” calls the abuse “a small minority of cases,” and says in so many words that the law “shall not be used to preclude a person with a disability from asserting their right to equal access.” Missouri kept none of it.

Kansas lets a plaintiff ask the attorney general to certify in writing, before filing, that their suit is not abusive, and to attach that to the complaint. Pre-clearance for legitimate claims. Missouri deleted it. Missouri’s attorney general can declare your case abusive. There is no path for anyone to declare it legitimate.

Kansas tells the court that the outcome of the accessibility case “shall be weighed heavily, particularly if the litigation was resolved in favor of the plaintiff.” Missouri’s version of that subsection is Kansas’s almost word for word, minus that sentence. In Missouri, winning your accessibility case earns you nothing in the counter-suit. Textually, nothing.

Kansas weighs the defendant’s size and resources, whether they had the means to fix the site, and whether the plaintiff and their lawyer are even from Kansas. Its whole stated target is out-of-state suits against small Kansas businesses. Missouri dropped all four. A Fortune 500 registrant gets exactly the shield a family shop gets.

Kansas’s law covers claims under “any other similar allegation under state or federal law,” which reaches Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Missouri’s covers the ADA “or under state law.” Section 504 is neither, and it’s the statute every federally funded university and school district is most exposed under. Missouri went out of its way to arm its public institutions and then defined the trigger so their biggest exposure falls outside it. Whether that was on purpose I can’t say. Nobody who could say has.

Kansas sunsets entirely the day the Department of Justice issues Title III web standards. Missouri’s sunset covers registered entities and public bodies and leaves individual Missourians’ counter-suit right permanent. Also, DOJ has been asked for Title III web standards for two decades and has just pushed its Title II deadlines to 2027. A sunset conditioned on something that isn’t going to happen is not a sunset. It’s the costume a permanent law wears while it’s being sold.

Any one of those edits you could call simplification. All of them together bend one way.

Every senator filed it with the protections in

This is the part that stopped me.

Three bills were merged into the final act, from three Republican senators. I read all three as introduced. Two of them, Hudson’s SB 907 and Trent’s SB 1272, are word-for-word Kansas: the conscience clause, the attorney general pre-clearance, the merits sentence, the size-and-resources factors, the 504 catch-all, the total sunset. All of it. The third, Nicola’s SB 1154, was softer than Kansas. It said a suit could only be abusive if its purpose was a settlement “unrelated to improving accessibility or enforcing accessibility rights,” and its 90-day safe harbor ran the opposite direction: if the business started fixing things, subsequent litigation was presumed not abusive.

Then the Senate General Laws Committee produced a substitute. The pre-clearance was gone. The merits sentence was gone. The proportionality factors were gone. The 504 catch-all was gone. Nicola’s plaintiff-protective presumption had been kept, with “is not abusive” flipped to “is abusive.” Public bodies, who appeared in none of the three bills, had been added. The committee’s chair was Trent, whose own bill contained every protection the substitute removed. No individual’s name is on any of the deletions. That’s what committee substitutes are for.

I pulled the committee minutes for all three hearings. Each one has a section headed “WITNESSES AGAINST.” Each one is blank. No disability organization, no plaintiff’s lawyer, no disabled Missourian, three hearings running. When the federal version of this idea, H.R. 620, reached the House floor in 2018, 236 disability rights organizations signed a letter against it. Here, nobody showed up, and I don’t think that’s because nobody cared. I think it’s because everyone had read the summary, and the summary said cure period.

Who did show up: the Missouri Chamber, three regional chambers, the retailers, the grocers, the NFIB, the insurance coalition, and the Missouri Civil Justice Reform Coalition, which is the tort reform lobby and which tells you what genre this law actually belongs to. It’s an anti-SLAPP statute pointed at civil rights plaintiffs, except real anti-SLAPP laws are a motion inside the same case with a merits test, and this is a second case with none. The one disability-adjacent organization in any of the three rooms was the association of sheltered workshop managers. The subminimum-wage employers. Testifying in support.

A small thing I keep turning over: the NFIB in the room was the National Federation of Independent Business. The National Federation of the Blind is the NFB. One letter apart. Only one of them was there.

There was exactly one recorded fight in this bill’s history. On March 24, Senator Stephen Webber offered an amendment: if the business fails to fix the site within its 90 days, the plaintiff may ask the attorney general to investigate or intervene on their side, and the AG’s website gets a complaint form for access violations. The state’s lawyer available to both parties. Roughly what Kansas already had. It went down on a voice vote, no roll call, the day before the Senate passed the bill 32 to 0. So when I wrote “without the partisan warfare,” I was right about the roll calls and wrong about the history. The disagreement existed. It was one amendment wide; it was about whether disabled Missourians would get a complaint form, and it was disposed of without anyone’s vote being recorded.

The ideal plaintiff

The bill was sold on serial filers, and specifically on a wave of demand letters to the state’s licensed cannabis dispensaries, which the industry’s own trade group called “tantamount to extortion” in the same sentence it conceded the barriers were real. I went looking for the actual cases. In the free federal docket data I could reach, there is one: Myers v. Shangri-La Jefferson, in the Western District of Missouri.

Robert Glen Myers is blind, uses a screen reader, and has filed thirteen ADA website cases in Missouri federal courts over two years. Under the enacted law, thirteen filings is factor (a), the one that counts prior suits against you. He is, on paper, exactly who the statute is for.

Here’s what the docket says he did. His lawyer sent Shangri-La written notice on August 19, 2024. He filed on November 22, three months later. The dispensary moved to dismiss on the ground that the site had been fixed, and its evidence was one affidavit from a marketing company’s creative director saying the site had been screen-reader compatible since October and every problem was “cured.” Myers’s expert re-audited in February and found sixteen specific barriers still there. The judge found the marketing director’s statement had “no evidentiary value,” called it inadmissible hearsay, found the audit “admissible and persuasive,” and let the case proceed. It settled that summer.

Run the new law’s own safe harbor against that record. Notice given. Ninety days for correction “as determined by the court.” A court actually made that determination, and the site wasn’t corrected. The one real dispensary case fails the statute’s own test, and it fails it in the direction of the plaintiff.

So if his other cases look like this one, and I can only verify the notice-first pattern in this one because the rest of the complaints aren’t in the free layer, Myers isn’t the problem the law describes. He’s the ideal plaintiff. A blind man who kept meeting barriers and refused to let any of them slide, for a statutory reward under Title III of zero dollars, because the ADA gives him an injunction and his lawyer’s fees and nothing else. What separates a person like that from a shakedown artist is notice, merit, and results. And the one factor built to measure results, the Kansas merits sentence, present in Hudson’s own bill as introduced, is the one the committee cut. The law kept the factor that counts his volume against him and deleted the factor that would have credited his vindication.

Three years, zero uses

Kansas has had this law since April 2023. I looked for any use of it. No court opinion cites it. No federal docket references it. Not one law firm alert, in three years, reports a business invoking it, and the defense bar that called it a “litigation sword” the week it passed would have written up a first swing. Kansas state court records can’t be searched by cause of action from where I sit, so a counter-suit could have been filed in a county courthouse and settled quietly. But the claim that survives is: no visible use in three years.

There are three ways to read that zero and I can’t rule any of them out. Maybe it deterred by existing and the letters dried up, which is unprovable because demand letters leave no records. Maybe the economics never worked even for defendants, since you’d pay a lawyer to sue a possibly judgment-proof out-of-state plaintiff, litigate personal jurisdiction, and then wait for the underlying case to finish before you could collect. Or maybe Kansas never had a problem to solve, since it has never once appeared on the national per-state filing chart, before the law or after.

Whichever it is, Missouri copied a statute with no enforcement history, and made it harsher, and armed its own government with it. The model didn’t spread because it worked. It spread because it existed.

What it’s for

This law is two weeks old as I write this and nobody has visibly used it yet. It may never be used. That’s the thing to understand about it. A law like this doesn’t need to survive a court challenge to do its job, and there are real challenges available: filing a lawsuit is protected petitioning, and a state penalizing people for exercising a federal right is the kind of thing federal courts sometimes have opinions about. But a challenge takes years and money and a plaintiff willing to be the test case. In the meantime, every disabled Missourian and every lawyer who might take their case has to price in a second lawsuit before filing the first one. The good plaintiffs, the ones with a real barrier and a letter and three months of patience, are the ones with the least money to absorb that. The serial shakedown artist has a business model. The blind man who can’t buy groceries has a grievance.

I called this proportionate in May, and for months afterward I believed it was a remediation window. What I’d read was coverage. So had everyone who described it that way, and, I suspect, most of the 148 people who voted for it. Nobody in three hearings read the text out loud, and the only disability-adjacent organization in the room was the sheltered workshop lobby.

But here’s what I can’t get past. The public may have misunderstood it as a cure period. Somewhere inside the legislative process, somebody understood the machinery well enough to remove every feature that protected legitimate plaintiffs. What survived is a single clause saying the Attorney General’s guidance “shall not preclude legitimate accessibility enforcement actions,” which protects a plaintiff from exactly nothing in the counter-suit.

The legislators should have read it. That’s the whole finding, and I know how naive it sounds. It’s one section. It was one section when they voted on it. Every senator who filed a version of this bill filed one with the protections in, and if any of them noticed that the thing they were voting for 32 to 0 wasn’t the thing they’d filed, it isn’t anywhere in the record. They read the summary. Everyone reads the summary.

And here’s the thing: I went and checked, and the summary was fine. Every version of this bill got a summary from the same Senate Research analyst, and every one of them opens with a resident filing “a civil action against the party, attorney, or law firm.” Nobody who read even the summary could have thought this was a remediation window. The cure-period story didn’t come from the statehouse’s own paperwork. It came from everyone who didn’t read that either.

What the summary couldn’t show them is what had been removed. The summary of the bill as introduced says that if the Attorney General finds a suit is not abusive, the plaintiff gets a presumption in their favor. The summary of the committee substitute simply doesn’t have that sentence anymore. No strikethrough, no “deleted,” nothing. The merits sentence and the proportionality factors never appear in any version’s summary at all, because every one says “the act describes the factors” and leaves it there. A summary describes what a bill does. It has no way to describe what it stopped doing. Only the diff shows absence, and nobody diffs.

You can’t trust the summaries. Not because they lie, this one didn’t, but because a summary can only show you what’s there. Not the bill summaries, not the press summaries, not the ones a machine writes for you. (I’ll keep coming back to that, because it’s not really a story about Missouri.) But this time the text is one section, it’s in HTML, and you can read it yourself. Time how long it takes you and consider that, too.